Bure Observations of CO in (sub)mm Galaxies
last update 3.3.04, 20h
Here is the IRAM Summer 2004 proposal draft: co-04s.ps.gz co-04s.tex
Link to Scott's list of targets Neri et al. ApJ Genzel et al. 2004, Venice
Summer 02: 3 Targets proposed and 3 observed and continued in Winter 02/03:
name Pr ID det CO S/N pk wid I_CO --offset-- z S350 comments
J044307.3+021023 12 MD-7 + 3-2 350 1.4 0.2 -1 -1 17 2.509 7.2 3arcsec extended #
M-15 - 7-6 0.4
+ cnt 3.7 1.1
J094303.7+470015 1 MB-7 + 4-3 420 1.1 0.1 -4 -1 -207 3.346 10.5 H6,wrong opt ID #&
+ cnt 5.8 2.3
J163650.4+405735 12 MA-7 + 3-2 840 2.3 0.2 115 2.3853 8.2 N2850.4 #&
M-14 + 7-6 1.1 0.2 -85 2.383
+ cnt 6.2 2.5
Winter 02/03: 6 Targets proposed and 6 observed: proposal.ps.gz
J105155.5+572313 2 MB5d - 4-3 (3.70) 4.5 LE850.18, z=0.3?
J105230.7+572210 2 MC5d - 3-2 2.6 11.0 LE850.6
J105238.3+572436 2 MD5d - 3-2 3.0 10.9 LE850.2
J163631.5+405547 2 ME5d - 3-2 2.28 6.3 N2850.13
J163639.0+405636 2 MF5d - 3-2 2.04 9.0 N2850.7 wrong z
NK28 (-) 3-2 1.49 more data
J163658.2+410523 2 MH5d + 3-2 7.8 1.8 700 1.3 0 0 -300 2.45 10.7 N2850.2 ERO &
Summer 03: 5 Targets proposed and 5 observed: proposal.ps.gz
J105124.6+572119 3 x 3-2 ~2.4 11.7
J123600.2+621047 3 NI28 - 3-2 1.989 2 sources not confirmed
+ cnt 3.8 2.5 3 -1
J123635.6+621424 3 x 3-2 ~2.0 4
J131201.1+424208 3 NC28 + 4-3 9.1 2.2 500 1.1 1 1 -400 3.408 6.2 extended
J131232.3+423950 3 ND28 - 3-2 2.32 5.9 latest z: 2.3257 Ha
J163651.4+410506 3 x 3-2 ~3.1 5.7 redshift wrong
J163706.5+405314 3 NJ28 (+) 3-2 3.7 1.2 brd 0 0 +400 2.378 12 MAMBO Elais(46)
J221733.2+000907 3 x 3-2 ~2.7 9.0
J221736.0+001554 3 NG28 (+) 3-2 4.1 .94 500 0.5 2 4 -400 3.097 6.3? (135)
J221804.4+002154 3 x 3-2 ~2.3 9.0
Winter 03/04: 8 Targets proposed and 0 observed: proposal.ps.gz
Object submm flux z CO frequ. CO freq ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ J123553.26+621337.7 (82) 8.8 +- 2.1 2.098 3-2 111.62 6-5 223.20 J123555.14+620901.7 (85) 6.0 +- 1.9 1.875 2-1 80.19 6-5 240.51 J123600.10+620253.5 (92) 6.9 +- 2.0 2.710 3-2 93.21 7-6 217.43 J123606.85+621021.4 (105) 11.6 +- 3.5 2.330 3-2 103.84 6-5 207.65 J123621.27+621708.4 (140) 7.8 +- 1.9 1.988 3-2 115.73 6-5 231.42 revised z, see below! J163627.94+405811.2 (e.43) 6.3 +- 1.9 3.180 3-2 82.73 7-6 220.53 J163655.75+405910.0 (m.20) 2.8 +- 0.7§ 2.607 3-2 96.05 7-6 223.63 revised z, see below! J221737.39+001025.1 (851) 6.1 +- 1.9 2.639 3-2 95.03 7-6 221.67 sa22_940 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ § at 1.2 mm with MAMBO
Two of these now have updated z and top priority:
coords submm flux redshift ID/comments ----------------------------------------------------------- SMMJ123621.27+621708.4 7.8 1.9 1.9925 #140 Halpha SMMJ163655.75+405910.0 3.1 1.0(mm) 2.5899 #mambo.20 -----------------------------------------------------------
Winter 2003/4: 3 High-resolution followup targets: proposal.ps.gz
J094303.7+470015 J163650.4+405735 J163658.2+410523
Summer 2004: New targets suggested by Scott:
coords 20cm R-mag (sub)mm redshift ID/comments ------------------------------------------------------------------------ SMMJ030244.56+000632.3 51.0 9.5 25.4 5.2 1.1 2.4345 #6 Ha SMMJ030227.73+000653.5 217.1 9.7 24.3 4.4 1.3 2.2574 #15 Ha SMMJ123549.44+621536.8 74.6 9.5 22.5 8.3 2.5 2.2032 HDF.76 Ha SMMJ123622.65+621629.7 70.9 8.7 24.3 7.7 1.3 2.4662 HDF.143 Ha SMMJ221733.79+001402.1 44.5 13.4 23.5 7.4 1.0 2.5553 22.139 Ha SMMJ131232.31+423949.5 94.8 3.3 24.1 4.7 1.1 2.3204 SA13.570 Ha, prev. obs. at 2.32 SMMJ123555.14+620901.7 212 14 6.0 1.8 1.865 HDF.85 LyA, (weak SiII,CII) SMMJ123707.21+621408.1 45 7.9 4.7 1.5 2.486 HDF.242 LyA ------------------------------------------------------------------------
Master list:
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
name Pr ID det CO S/N pk wid I_CO --offset-- z S350 alias & comments
mJy kms Jy*km/s " " km/s mJy
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
J044307.3+021023 12 MD-7 + 3-2 350 1.4 0.2 -1 -1 17 2.509 7.2 3arcsec extended #
M-15 - 7-6 0.4
+ cnt 3.7 1.1
J094303.7+470015 1 MB-7 + 4-3 420 1.1 0.1 -4 -1 -207 3.346 10.5 H6,wrong opt ID #&
+ cnt 5.8 2.3
J105124.6+572119 3 x 3-2 ~2.4 11.7
J105155.5+572313 2 MB5d - 4-3 (3.70) 4.5 LE850.18, z=0.3?
J105230.7+572210 2 MC5d - 3-2 2.6 11.0 LE850.6
J105238.3+572436 2 MD5d - 3-2 3.0 10.9 LE850.2
J123553.3+621338 4 3-2 2.098 8.8+-2.1 (82)
J123555.1+620902 4 2-1 1.875 6.0+-1.9 (85)
J123600.1+620254 4 3-2 2.710 6.9+-2.0 (92)
J123600.2+621047 3 NI28 - 3-2 1.989 (2 sources not confirmed)
+ cnt 3.8 2.5 3 -1
J123606.8+621021 4 3-2 2.330 11.6+-3.5 (105)
J123621.3+621709 4 3-2 1.988 7.8+-1.9 (140)
J163627.9+405811 4 3-2 3.180 6.3+-1.9 (e.43)
J123635.6+621424 3 x 3-2 ~2.0 4
J131201.1+424208 3 NC28 + 4-3 9.1 2.2 500 1.1 1 1 -400 3.408 6.2 extended
J131232.3+423950 3 ND28 - 3-2 2.32 5.9
J163631.5+405547 2 ME5d - 3-2 2.28 6.3 N2850.13
J163639.0+405636 2 MF5d - 3-2 2.04 9.0 N2850.7 wrong z
NK28 (-) 3-2 1.49 more data
J163650.4+405735 12 MA-7 + 3-2 840 2.3 0.2 115 2.3853 8.2 N2850.4 #&
M-14 + 7-6 1.1 0.2 -85 2.383
+ cnt 6.2 2.5
J163651.4+410506 3 x 3-2 ~3.1 5.7 redshift wrong
J163655.7+405910 4 3-2 2.607 2.8+-0.7 (m.20) MAMBO
J163658.2+410523 2 MH5d + 3-2 7.8 1.8 700 1.3 0 0 -300 2.45 10.7 N2850.2 ERO &
J163706.5+405314 3 NJ28 (+) 3-2 3.7 1.2 brd 0 0 +400 2.378 12 MAMBO Elais(46)
J221733.2+000907 3 x 3-2 ~2.7 9.0
J221735.1+001533 4 NG28 3-2 (2.38) 6 (136) LyA Ha
J221736.0+001554 3 NG28 (+) 3-2 4.1 .94 500 0.5 2 4 -400 3.097 6.3? (135)
J221737.4+001025 4 3-2 2.639 6.1+-1.9 (851) sa22_940
J221804.4+002154 3 x 3-2 ~2.3 9.0
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
(1) Object name, i.e. coordinate
(2) Proposal: 1=S02, 2=W02/03, 3=S03, 4=W03/04, 5=S04
(3) IRAM program ID, x= object replaced by other
(4) + detected, - not detected, ? unknown status, () uncertain
(5) CO transition or continuum
(6) signal to noise of line peak intensity
(7) peak line flux
(8) line FWHM
(9)-(10) integrated line flux and uncertainty, sigma
(11)-(13) offset in position and velocity from optical source
(14) redshift of CO line, or (~) optical z
(15) 850 um = 350 GHz continuum flux density
(16) SMM source alt. name, comments
# Neri et al. 2003, ApJ Letters, in press
& High resolution followup proposed, Neri et al.
Comments:
J044307.3+021023 possibly complex lensing
J105124.6+572119 no robust radio, redshift good, coord = 105224
J105155.5+572313 Ian says this source is at z=0.3 ?
J105230.7+572210 and J105238.3+572436, no flux limits yet
J123635.6+621424 good radio ID, SCUBA flux came down.
J163706.5+405314 MAMBO source followed up with SCUBA photometry
J221733.2+000907 new Keck data: z correct. Needs more analysis
J221736.0+001554 There is confusion with J221735.1+001533. Possible latter was targeted
with the redshift of former.
 |
Far-IR luminosity vs. CO luminosity.
(T.Greve) Click image for larger version. ps |
 |
CO luminosity vs. redshift.
(T.Greve) Click image for larger version. ps |
